Dr. Betsy Brydon, Gynecologic Oncologist closes her private practice
April 1, 2010 and will not be accepting new patients or be on the regular
schedule for gynecologic cancer surgeries.This closure comes after two years of notice to the Ministry of Health
that working conditions for women's cancer specialists were unworkable and
needed attention.Specifically, in no
other jurisdiction (including Saskatoon) are these specialists required to
acquire private offices to practice.Normally, these specialists would work in a hospital setting with all
the support that provides.This means
that the two Regina gynecologic oncologists must work without proper nursing
support.
After two years of notification, two years of letter writing and meetings, no action was taken to prevent this closure. You can help!
Darlene Gray, Director of OCATS (Ovarian Cancer Awareness &
Treatment in Sask) said, "This is the news we have been anticipating and
dreading, the very situation we alerted the Minister of Health of and had hoped
the Ministry would provide the leadership and resources to prevent. Gynecologic cancer patients, ovarian cancer
patients in particular who face a very low survival rate, are dependent on
these specialists - for us it's a matter of life and death. Now the burdeon in southern Saskatchewan
rests on the shoulders of one doctor, creating even more delicate working
conditions."
Gynecologic oncologists, as women's specialized care providers, remain
an internationally accepted and indisputable fact and yet we are faced with a
situation where these widely sought specialists are not retainable in
Regina. Gray said, "The public should
be very concerned about this severe situation in the delivery of, or lack of,
cancer care in Saskatchewan. The lack
of attention to patients' voices is equally disturbing. The public needs to be
asking why and to be asking it now."
This development should not come as a surprise as doctors and patients
having been seeking leadership from the Ministry of Health over the past 2
years. The Sask Cancer Agency also
received several requests for proper nursing support. The Regina Qu'Appelle Health Region was requested to provide
appropriate hospital space for the gynecologic oncologists. Last spring Dr. Brydon and OCATS advised the
public that gynecologic oncology treatment could not continue under the current
substandard working conditions. Simple
solutions presented were unheeded and no department or agency or group acted on
behalf of the patients in Saskatchewan. "After all our Survivors' work it's difficult to witness Dr. Brydon's departure when it could have been so easily
avoided," Gray said.
To prepare for her departure Dr. Brydon has taken on other contractual
assignments and maintains a one-day a week contract with the Allan Blair Cancer
Centre, which will allow her to continue care for existing patients requiring
surgery or therapy. However, the
majority of new patients formally referred to two specialists must now be
referred to only one. Gray said, "We
wonder if patients can not be seen in a timely fashion by the remaining
specialist, will they have to travel to Saskatoon? We wonder if patients cannot be seen in a timely fashion in
Saskatoon, will they be sent out of province? We fear that the recruitment of a replacement doctor is in jeopardy
because the working conditions have now worsened," Gray said.
OCATS is asking for four simple inexpensive actions to be taken immediately:
1. funding directly to the remaining gyne onc to hire proper nursing support
2. office/examination space at the RGH for the remaining gyne onc
3. change outdated SaskHealth policy to read "hysterectomies for cancer surgery are performed by gynecologic oncologists" (rather than "gynecologists" as it now states).
4. assign a COMMUNICATOR the working conditions and program development issues to keep all parties and individuals involved on tract, working towards an end date and accountable. This includes the gyne oncs, administrators, agencies, departments, regions and the Ministry.
If you want to support this please send your letter to the Minister of Health, Don McMorris, Rm 302, Leg Bldg 2405 Legislative
Drive, Regina, SK S4S 0B3, 787-7345,
Comments
Letter to Editor, LP Written by Darlene on 2010-04-12 12:14:13Dear Editor: We want to thank Pam Cowan for an excellent article about Dr. Brydon, Regina Gynecologic Oncologist being forced to walk away from her practice (LP, Apr 9/10) but what a crying shame to see this happen after two years of educating the Ministry of Health about the risk of losing this specialist so needed for gyne cancer patients in Southern Sask. We must ask again, why is Sask having such a difficult time retaining cancer specialists? In the various reasons for Dr. Brydon’s physical and emotional frustration the brutal winter weather was never mentioned. It would have been so easy and inexpensive to have prevented this office closure. Some oncology nursing support, some in-hospital office space, some ownership by the Ministry of the problem in Saskatchewan with the delivery of gyne cancer care. It’s not so complicated and it has been dealt with very well in all other jurisdictions in Canada. Why is Sask willing to let women’s lives hang in the balance doing more study and design with no clear objectives and date for completion, while great examples for a gyne onc program are all around us?
Ms. Jordon of SaskHealth is quoted in the article as stating that while the RQHR recruits a gyne oncologist “referrals will be made to other providers such as gynecologists”! This is alarming. Gynecologists in Sask are great at what they do, but they are not trained, experienced or necessarily have the skills to tenderly lift up vital organs and scrape cancer cells away, remove organs from the abdomen and do a thorough search for lurking cancer cells. One of the most challenging parts of a hysterectomy performed for a patient suspected of having cancer can be the cutting away of cancer cells that have attached to the bowels. This can mean life or death right on the operating table if not done perfectly. If Dr. Brydon feels her skills aren’t up to par, what is the chance that a regular gynecologist can replace her? This is a tragedy for the women of Saskatchewan. It seems delivery of Sask gyne cancer care is going backwards.
Also backward is Jordon’s stated aim to “coordinate care for women and provide information about services, but not to set up a physical unit”. This flies in the face of proper standard gyne cancer care delivery, hardly a recruitment strategy to lure skilled gyne oncologists to Saskatchewan. It’s not like no one knows – about a year ago a mentor in the delivery of gyne cancer care, Dr. Ehlan, from the BC Cancer Centre was in Saskatchewan doing a presentation on an excellent program in BC. This is just one piece of information provided to SaskHealth.
We’re also very curious about Jordan’s interpretation of patients’ input in the Patient First Review. I guess she hasn’t read our contribution. We can’t visualize “hands-off of care” but know this – for patient-centered care a gyne cancer UNIT is definitely needed in Regina and in Saskatoon and is a world wide standard and expected by all gyne oncology graduates. Without an actual UNIT for care, how can specialized delivery of intraperitoneal chemotherapy be delivered? Where will our gyne oncologists be based? Where will the radiologists, pathologists, oncology nurses go for advice, consultations, supplies, information? Like the Breast Health Clinic in the Pasqua Hospital, a Gyne Cancer Unit will lead to better care, understanding, diagnosis, treatment and awareness. Why wouldn’t this be part of a Sask gyne oncology program?
We concur with Dr. Brydon’s suggestion that someone in the Ministry of Health, SaskHealth, health districts, cancer agencies and department needs to own the problem. We suggest that the Ministry assign a Communicator immediately and bring the gyne cancer program working committee together properly with a time line and simple parameters to ensure high quality work in a short period of time and holds the participants accountable. We need to stop wasting time and putting women’s lives at risk. We need to implement a program, provide proper support/offices/nursing, update outdated Sask gyne cancer policy. It’s time for women in Saskatchewan to take notice and ask for what is needed – before being diagnosed! We can assure you that once you are fighting cancer, it’s very difficult to also try to advocate for a proper doctor.
Darlene Gray, On Behalf of OCATS Ovarian Cancer Awareness & Treatment in Saskatchewan www.ocats.ca
Only registered users can write comments. Please login or register.
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owners. Opinions expressed in articles within this site are those of their owners and may not reflect the opinion of ActUpInSask.org, its staff, or its associates.